American Airlines recently revised its internal policies governing when flight attendants can ask passengers to leave the plane. These changes come amid a rise in complaints against airlines alleging discriminatory behavior.
Especially in the wake of the pandemic, reports of conflicts between flight attendants and passengers have increased, highlighting the need for strengthened policies. The new policy aims to ensure that such incidents are handled carefully and only under clearly defined conditions, with safety concerns being paramount.
The development of the guidelines
In recent years, there have been increasing reports of aggressive incidents between passengers and cabin crew. Many of these incidents, in which passengers had to leave the aircraft, have been critically scrutinized by the public. It often seemed as if such escalations could have been defused by a different approach. American Airlines responded to these concerns by revising its internal regulations. The airline has now made it clear that passengers may only be asked to leave the aircraft if there is an actual safety problem.
This means that if a non-safety issue arises, flight attendants should try to de-escalate the situation so that the passenger does not have to be removed. Only if such an issue is raised by a customer should the cabin crew respond. Another important point is that the captain continues to have the final say if the situation escalates and a final decision needs to be made.
The incident with the passengers from Phoenix
The need for these adjustments was particularly evident in an incident in January 2024. At that time, eight men were removed from an American Airlines plane flying from Phoenix to New York. The reason for the measure was a complaint from passengers about unpleasant body odor. All of the men affected were African American, did not sit together and did not know each other. The removal of the passengers led to a discrimination lawsuit that later attracted a lot of public attention.
In response to the incident, American Airlines CEO Robert Isom acknowledged that the behavior in this case was "unacceptable" and contrary to the airline's values. He stressed that it was an unfortunate mistake that did not reflect the airline's principles of respect and care for all customers. As a result, an "Oversight and Excellence Advisory Group" was established to improve the experience of black customers and critically review internal practices, particularly with regard to passenger removal.
Increasing complaints about discriminatory behavior
The incident and the actions that followed are part of a larger trend that is emerging in the aviation sector. According to the U.S. Department of Transportation (DOT), the number of complaints dealing with discriminatory behavior in air travel increased significantly in 2023. While 2022 complaints were registered in 176, there were already more than 2023 in 220 - an increase of 26%. The American Airlines policy change is a response to this trend and is intended to help prevent such situations.
Another example of the problem can be seen in the company's response to customer complaints about discrimination, which have led to repeated escalations in the past. In addition to setting up the advisory group, American Airlines has also pledged to intensify training for cabin crew on how to deal with sensitive situations. Training on diversity and inclusion is to be increased, particularly after the traumatic experiences of affected passengers.
The impact on the aviation industry
American Airlines' decision to revise its passenger removal policy could send an important signal to the entire airline industry. With increasing sensitivity to issues of discrimination and customer service, many airlines are responding by refining their internal procedures for treating passengers. Establishing clear and transparently defined rules for such situations could help build passenger confidence and prevent similar incidents in the future.
In addition, the industry as a whole could move in a direction in which not only airlines, but also airports and other service providers are held more accountable for creating an environment of inclusion and respect. Airlines such as American Airlines, which place greater emphasis on training and preventive measures, could act as role models and initiate positive changes.
and 