The low-cost airline Ryanair recently made a move to relax the night flight bans in Germany to avoid delays and flight diversions. However, this proposal was rejected by the Federal Ministry of Transport, which invoked the jurisdiction of the federal states. Ryanair, which has been in dispute with the federal government on various issues for months, presented the move as urgently necessary, as planes that wanted to land after midnight due to delays were repeatedly diverted to Hanover.
The dispute between Ryanair and the German government is nothing new. Tensions have been a constant, particularly over night flight bans and the associated restrictions for airlines. Michael O'Leary, CEO of the Ryanair Group, has repeatedly criticized German regulations in the past, which he believes are not in the interests of passengers and the aviation industry. This latest move by Ryanair is also part of a series of demands by which the airline is trying to optimize its operations and minimize inconvenience for its passengers.
Ryanair’s initiative and the ministry’s reaction
Ryanair again criticised the existing night flight bans, in particular the regulations that prevent planes from landing at Berlin-Brandenburg Airport if they are delayed after midnight. In a recently published case, a Ryanair plane landed just 90 seconds after the start of the night flight ban, which led to passengers being diverted to Hanover. These passengers had to wait several hours for the bus back to Berlin, which Ryanair described as a "scandal". The airline appealed to Federal Transport Minister Volker Wissing (independent) to take immediate action to prevent such situations in the future.
However, the Federal Ministry of Transport's response was negative. A spokesman for the ministry pointed out that the night flight ban in Germany is the responsibility of the federal states and cannot be changed by the federal government. Ryanair therefore only has the option of turning to the respective state authorities. This response highlights the existing tension between the airline and the responsible German authorities, who regularly come into conflict with Ryanair when it comes to air traffic regulations.
Night flight bans and their effects on air traffic
Night flight bans are a common practice in many countries to protect residents living near airports from noise. In Germany, the rules for night flights are strict, especially at major airports such as Berlin-Brandenburg, Frankfurt and Munich. Airlines must adhere to these regulations, which can result in delayed flights after midnight being diverted or cancelled altogether. This often causes significant inconvenience for the passengers affected, as they cannot reach their destinations or have to endure longer waiting times.
The problem is particularly evident for low-cost airlines such as Ryanair, which rely on a tight schedule and fast processing of their flights to keep their costs low and ensure competitiveness. Delays caused by the night flight bans are a major problem for such airlines. Passengers are sometimes disappointed and angry, especially when flights affected by delayed connections have to be diverted after long waiting times in order to comply with the rules.
The government's reactions and the dispute with Ryanair
Ryanair's demand to change the night flight ban is not the airline's first move to meet resistance from the German government. In 2024, Michael O'Leary had already made another move, calling for a reduction in the air traffic tax and a cap on aviation security fees. This attempt also met with little approval from the federal government. O'Leary spoke of a missed opportunity when he noted in an interview with the trade magazine airliners.de that he had made an offer to the Federal Chancellery in 2024 that included doubling passenger numbers and investing three billion euros in Germany. But the federal government did not understand this offer, said O'Leary.
Ryanair increasingly sees itself as a company that could make significant contributions to the aviation industry in Germany if regulatory hurdles were removed. Given Ryanair's repeated demands, some of which are gaining attention through media and public debate, the airline may also continue to seek to exert political influence to change the rules it sees as hindering its business practices.
The dispute between Ryanair and the German government over the night flight bans and other aviation-related regulations is a reflection of the broader tensions between low-cost airlines and national regulators. Ryanair continues to lobby aggressively to ease operational restrictions, while the German government typically insists on protecting local residents and upholding safety standards.
In the current situation, it remains to be seen whether there will be a change in the night flight regulations or whether Ryanair will have to adapt its strategy to better adapt to the German situation. However, it is to be expected that discussions about night flight bans and the associated regulations will continue in the coming months.
and 