The chronic unpunctuality of Deutsche Bahn has far-reaching consequences for international rail traffic, especially for connections to Switzerland. The inadequate punctuality of German trains not only affects passengers in Germany, but also has a direct impact on cross-border traffic. The Swiss Federal Railways (SBB) have responded to this problem by stopping many trains at the border, causing significant delays and inconvenience for travelers.
Punctuality in Deutsche Bahn's long-distance services has been a pressing problem for years. In 2023, only 64 percent of trains arrived at their destination on time, with a generous buffer of six minutes already taken into account. These figures reflect Deutsche Bahn's ongoing difficulties in terms of operational management and infrastructure. The ongoing delays not only affect passengers in Germany, but also lead to problems with international connections.
Deutsche Bahn's delays have a significant impact on cross-border traffic to Switzerland. In the first quarter of 2024, according to a response from the Federal Ministry of Transport to a request from Bundestag member Matthias Gastel (Greens), eleven percent of all German trains on the Munich-Zurich route were stopped at the border. This represents a drastic increase compared to the previous year, when only two percent of trains were stopped. On the Freiburg-Basel route, 12,4 percent of trains had to turn around, compared to less than ten percent last year. These measures by SBB are a direct response to the repeated delays and have significant consequences for travelers.
Punctuality and timetable of the Swiss railways
The Swiss Federal Railways (SBB) are known for their high level of punctuality. In 2023, the SBB's punctuality rate was 92,5 percent. The Swiss regular timetable contributes significantly to this high level of punctuality. This plan ensures that trains regularly meet at the same place at the same time and that connections work reliably. In hub stations such as Bern, long-distance trains are concentrated around the hour and half hour, while regional trains are grouped around the 15th and 45th minute. This precise planning ensures that SBB passengers reach their destinations on time and can use connections without any problems.
The delays of German trains on the route between Munich and Zurich are mainly due to infrastructure problems. Construction work, overhead line damage and single-track sections in both directions led to delays in three quarters of the cases and thus to border stops. On the Rhine Valley Railway route, only around a third of the trains stopped were due to infrastructure problems. However, almost half of the delays resulted from strikes by the German Train Drivers' Union (GDL), which significantly disrupted operations.
SBB measures and solutions
In order to minimize the impact of delays on the Swiss rail system, SBB, in cooperation with Deutsche Bahn, introduced temporary measures in 2022 that have now become a permanent solution. These measures aim to reduce the effects of delays on the Swiss rail system and to ensure the integrity of the regular timetable.
The unpunctuality of Deutsche Bahn has serious consequences for cross-border traffic to Switzerland. While the Swiss railways achieve high punctuality rates thanks to their strict timetable, Deutsche Bahn continues to struggle with considerable challenges. The SBB's measures are necessary to minimize the negative effects on international rail traffic and to ensure the reliability of connections.
and 