Easyjet refused the passenger carriage - according to the Supreme Court wrongly

Airbus A320 (Photo: Jan Gruber).
Airbus A320 (Photo: Jan Gruber).

Easyjet refused the passenger carriage - according to the Supreme Court wrongly

Airbus A320 (Photo: Jan Gruber).
Advertising

OGH: Airline exceeded its powers in the course of reviewing official documents.

The British low-cost airline refused an Iraqi citizen a flight from Vienna to London due to an alleged lack of a visa. An existing valid residence card that would have entitled entry without a visa was not accepted by EasyJet. Because the company assumed that the person concerned did not actually meet the requirements for the residence card – issued by the authorities. The refusal of carriage was inadmissible, the Supreme Court (OGH) has now ruled in a procedure conducted by the Association for Consumer Information (VKI). 

As a result, the carrier has to reimburse the costs for the expired flight tickets and make compensation payments – twice over: to the person concerned and his wife who is traveling with him. The wife could have claimed her ticket, but the husband's refusal to board was ultimately equivalent to his wife's refusal to board, the court said.

“Easyjet has assumed the authority here to question whether the residence card was lawfully issued by the Austrian authorities. The verification of such a document must be limited to the authenticity and correctness of the information contained therein. With this residence card, Easyjet had no concrete indications of abuse of rights or fraud," commented VKI lawyer Verena Grubner on the verdict.

Easyjet accepts the verdict

"Easyjet, like all other airlines, is required by the relevant authorities to ensure that all passengers are able to present the correct, valid travel documents to ensure the safety of all passengers and crew," an airline spokesman told Aviation.Direct. "We regret that the passenger concerned was wrongly denied boarding on his flight to London and will reimburse him for the additional costs incurred as a result, in accordance with the Court's ruling."

3 Comments

  • Marcus, 26. April 2022 @ 19: 02

    Please do not make false claims here. A residence permit issued by Austria does not entitle you to enter the UK as non-Schengen and the British have never recognized Schengen permits, just as we do not recognize British residence permits. With a Schenaufenthal permit, you can at most transfer in the UK to another Schengen destination. Unfortunately, asylum seekers abuse this opportunity again and again. Obviously, the passenger in question had serious doubts as to whether he was actually only changing planes in London and not trying to apply for asylum in the UK!

    • Jan Gruber, 26. April 2022 @ 20: 26

      You are quite wrong as far as the state of affairs in May 2018 is concerned. At the time of the incident, the United Kingdom was still a member of the European Union. You could enter the UK with residence permits from other EU countries, just as holders of UK permits could enter the Schengen area. Mind you: For tourism purposes without a work and/or settlement permit - that would be a completely different topic.
      As far as the current situation is concerned: Correct, an AT residence permit does not entitle you to enter the UK and vice versa a UK residence permit does not entitle you to enter the Schengen area. To be precise: it has been like this since February 1, 2020.

  • Marcus, 27. April 2022 @ 19: 10

    I'm definitely not "really wrong". What you write is total nonsense. sorry What you may mean, but generally misrepresent here, are family member residence permits for people who require a visa and who are married to EU citizens. But it was only possible if they traveled together with the person who has an EU passport. But that is something completely different than third-country nationals who need a visa for the UK, who have a Schengen residence permit or multiple Schengen visas and are not married to EU citizens. That's what I was talking about. For example, people with a Serbian or Bosnian passport who live in Vienna with a residence permit. And their relatives only have a Bosnian or Serbian passport. These people have never been able to enter the UK without a visa – not even when the UK was a member of the EU. The Schengen title only entitles you to continue your journey to another Schengen destination! And there was and still is some doubt as to whether they are abusing this rule to apply for asylum in the UK or simply stay there illegally.

Leave a Comment

Your e-mail address will not be published. Required fields are marked with * marked

This website uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn more about how your comment data is processed.

Editor of this article:

Granit Pireci is an editor at Aviation.Direct and specializes in aviation in Southeast Europe. Before that he worked for AviationNetOnline (formerly Austrian Aviation Net).
[ssba buttons]

Nobody likes paywalls
- not even Aviation.Direct!

Information should be free for everyone, but good journalism costs a lot of money.

If you enjoyed this article, you can check Aviation.Direct voluntary for a cup of coffee Coffee trail (for them it's free to use).

In doing so, you support the journalistic work of our independent specialist portal for aviation, travel and tourism with a focus on the DA-CH region voluntarily without a paywall requirement.

If you did not like the article, we look forward to your constructive criticism and / or your suggestions for improvement, either directly to the editor or to the team at with this link or alternatively via the comments.

Your
Aviation.Direct team
paywalls
nobody likes!

About the editor

Granit Pireci is an editor at Aviation.Direct and specializes in aviation in Southeast Europe. Before that he worked for AviationNetOnline (formerly Austrian Aviation Net).
[ssba buttons]

Nobody likes paywalls
- not even Aviation.Direct!

Information should be free for everyone, but good journalism costs a lot of money.

If you enjoyed this article, you can check Aviation.Direct voluntary for a cup of coffee Coffee trail (for them it's free to use).

In doing so, you support the journalistic work of our independent specialist portal for aviation, travel and tourism with a focus on the DA-CH region voluntarily without a paywall requirement.

If you did not like the article, we look forward to your constructive criticism and / or your suggestions for improvement, either directly to the editor or to the team at with this link or alternatively via the comments.

Your
Aviation.Direct team
paywalls
nobody likes!

3 Comments

  • Marcus, 26. April 2022 @ 19: 02

    Please do not make false claims here. A residence permit issued by Austria does not entitle you to enter the UK as non-Schengen and the British have never recognized Schengen permits, just as we do not recognize British residence permits. With a Schenaufenthal permit, you can at most transfer in the UK to another Schengen destination. Unfortunately, asylum seekers abuse this opportunity again and again. Obviously, the passenger in question had serious doubts as to whether he was actually only changing planes in London and not trying to apply for asylum in the UK!

    • Jan Gruber, 26. April 2022 @ 20: 26

      You are quite wrong as far as the state of affairs in May 2018 is concerned. At the time of the incident, the United Kingdom was still a member of the European Union. You could enter the UK with residence permits from other EU countries, just as holders of UK permits could enter the Schengen area. Mind you: For tourism purposes without a work and/or settlement permit - that would be a completely different topic.
      As far as the current situation is concerned: Correct, an AT residence permit does not entitle you to enter the UK and vice versa a UK residence permit does not entitle you to enter the Schengen area. To be precise: it has been like this since February 1, 2020.

  • Marcus, 27. April 2022 @ 19: 10

    I'm definitely not "really wrong". What you write is total nonsense. sorry What you may mean, but generally misrepresent here, are family member residence permits for people who require a visa and who are married to EU citizens. But it was only possible if they traveled together with the person who has an EU passport. But that is something completely different than third-country nationals who need a visa for the UK, who have a Schengen residence permit or multiple Schengen visas and are not married to EU citizens. That's what I was talking about. For example, people with a Serbian or Bosnian passport who live in Vienna with a residence permit. And their relatives only have a Bosnian or Serbian passport. These people have never been able to enter the UK without a visa – not even when the UK was a member of the EU. The Schengen title only entitles you to continue your journey to another Schengen destination! And there was and still is some doubt as to whether they are abusing this rule to apply for asylum in the UK or simply stay there illegally.

Leave a Comment

Your e-mail address will not be published. Required fields are marked with * marked

This website uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn more about how your comment data is processed.

Advertising